http://www.researchforum.org/project_general_323.html

Explaining Recent Trends in Food Stamp Program Caseloads

General Information

View a brief abstract of this project.

View a complete, printer-friendly profile of this project.

Evaluator(s) Abt Associates, Inc.
Investigator(s) Robert Kornfeld (Abt Associates, Inc.)
Sponsor(s) Not applicable
Funder(s) US Department of Agriculture
Consultant(s) Not applicable
Subcontractor(s) Not applicable
 
Domain Income Security/TANF
Status Completed (final report released)
Type Research and/or Program Evaluation
Goal This report analyzes the possible effects of the economy and recent policy changes on trends in food stamp caseloads from 1987-1999, and seeks to account for the sharp decline in caseloads after 1994. The report studies food stamp receipt among different types of households — such as single- and multiple-adult households with children, and adults and elderly persons living separately —because recent policy changes probably had different impacts on different types of households. The proportion of the population receiving food stamps is estimated for each type of household and for each state and year from 1987 to 1999, using administrative data on food stamp participants and population data from the Current Population Survey. This report analyzes the relationship between these measures of caseloads and measures of economic trends and policy changes, taking advantage of the “natural experiment” provided by variation in policy changes across states and over time.
Program/Policy Description The study analyzed food stamp receipt among different types of households, such as single- and multiple-adult households with children and adults and elderly persons living separately.
Notes No notes reported.
 
Last Updated 03/20/03
Type of Summary Reviewed
External Reviewer(s) Robert Kornfeld (Abt Associates, Inc.)
Contact(s) Robert Kornfeld (Robert_Kornfeld@abtassoc.com)
Abt Associates, Inc.
4800 Montgomery Lane
(T) (301) - 913-0593
(F) (301) 718-3108
Publications Department Abt Publications (not reported)
Abt Associates, Inc.
4808 Montgomery Lane
(T) not reported
(F) not reported
Submitter(s) Robert Kornfeld (Robert_Kornfeld@abtassoc.com)
Abt Associates, Inc.
4800 Montgomery Lane
(T) (301) - 913-0593
(F) (301) 718-3108

Populations Studied

Target Population Single parent families
Two-parent families
Low-income households
Subgroups Analyzed None
Sample Size and Unit Approximately 50,000 households of food stamp recipients and leavers from 1987-1999
Execution This study analyzes the proportion of the population that receives food stamps by state, by year (1987-1999), and by type of household (single- and multiple-adult households with children, adults and elderly living separately, elderly living with others, and child-only units.)

Sites Studied

All 50 states and Washington DC

Program Components, Policies, and Activities Evaluated

Employment activities

  • Job search

Financial incentives

  • Earnings disregards
  • Financial Incentives - misc.

Financial disincentives/Sanctions

  • Reduced benefits for non-compliance
  • Strengthened JOBS sanctions
  • Multi-program sanctions
  • Financial Disincentives/Sanctions - misc.

Program requirements

  • Work requirement
  • Broadened JOBS participation requirement
  • Program Requirements - misc.

Administration/Implementation

  • Program enforcement of sanctions
  • Development of new welfare policies
  • Administration/Implementation - misc.

Time limits

  • Time Limits - misc.

Family caps

  • Family Caps - misc.

Food stamps

  • Food Stamps - misc.

Diversionary activities

  • Diversionary activities - misc.
Variation in program components across sites? Yes
Notes on program components N/A

Outcomes Assessed

Caseload Dynamics

  • Caseload dynamics - misc.

Types of Studies

Type Impact Study (Quasi-experiment with non-equivalent control groups)
Aim To analyzes how policy changes and economic factors may have affected trends in the number of food stamp participants from several different types of households from 1987-1999.
 

Data Sources

Source Survey
Title Current Population Survey
Sample Characteristics/Data Collection Population by type of household, by state, and by year, 1987-1999
Sites All 50 states and D.C.
Response Rate/Attrition Notes N/A
Additional Execution Notes No notes reported.
 
Source Administrative data
Title Food Stamp Program Quality Control data
Sample Characteristics/Data Collection Recipients by type of household, by state, and by year, 1987-1999; about 50,000 recipients each year
Sites All 50 states and D.C.
Response Rate/Attrition Notes N/A
Additional Execution Notes No notes reported.
 

Findings Available

Final Impact Findings
Final Descriptive/Analytical Findings

Findings

03/02/02: Explaining Trends in Food Stamp Program Caseloads: Final Report
Final Impact Findings:

The main findings, which are estimated using minimal controls for other potential determinants of food stamp receipt, confirm that different types of households were affected in different ways by the economy and policy changes. The economy has an especially strong effect on caseloads from multiple adult households with children and adults living separately. Shorter recertification periods also reduce food stamp caseloads from these two types of households, which include many working poor food stamp participants. TANF sanctions reduce caseloads from households with children, and Electronic Benefits Transfer (EBT) systems increase caseloads.

The main findings indicate that the economy explains at least 19 percent of the total caseload decline from 1994 to 1999, FSP reporting requirements explain another 8 percent of the decline, and several measures of specific components of TANF plans together account for another 21 percent of the decline. Restricted eligibility for noncitizens and adults without dependents could account for perhaps 10 percent of the decline. These main findings should, however, be viewed with caution because the estimated effects of TANF are sensitive to the inclusion of additional controls for other factors that may also influence caseloads, and because some of the estimated effects of TANF policies persist among households that do not include children. These findings show that it is not easy to separate the effects of policy changes and other factors on caseloads trends in the late 1990s. The results nevertheless indicate the recent policy changes may account for some of the recent food stamp caseload decline.

 

Recommendations

Explaining Trends in Food Stamp Program Caseloads: Final Report (03/02/02)
None reported.
 

Existing Publications

03/02/02 Explaining Trends in Food Stamp Program Caseloads: Final Report Abt